Mama Maria's Pizza

Mama Maria’s Pizza is exactly what hungry Put-in-Bay visitors need after a long day on the boat or a night spent bar hopping in downtown. This pizzeria stays open til the bars close and sometimes even later. Grab a slice before heading home to ward off that hangover!

Mama Maria’s Pizza Details

Fast and convenient, Mama Maria’s slings piping hot pizza topped with fresh ingredients, fun toppings, and plenty of gooey cheese and flavorful sauce. The meatball subs are really amazing. The subs are made with succulent all-beef meatballs wrapped in a fresh, crunch roll and topped with so much cheese, you can barely see the meatballs! Tasty wraps round out their menu.

Imagine digging into one of the meatball subs or piping hot slice after partying it up at Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill all night long. The perfect ending to an amazing Put-in-Bay night.

Location Location Location

Mama Maria’s Pizza’s location couldn’t be more perfect. Right on Delaware Avenue, this pizzeria is in the center of the action. The patio is perfect for people watching. Grab lunch here after exploring the island and take in the heart and soul of Put-in-Bay. Mama Maria’s Pizza is also feet away from the best bars on the island and minutes from the Jet Express Terminal.

Downtown Put-in-Bay

The streets of downtown Put-in-Bay are lined with shops, restaurants, and bars and always brimming with activity. Visitors flock here for the friendly atmosphere and world class entertainment. First-timers to the island have a blast exploring and regulars look forward to revisiting their favorites.

DeRivera Park is green center of the downtown. This beautiful oasis provides picnic tables, BBQ grills, a playground, and gazebo. Public bathrooms and showers are also available as are the public The DeRivera Park B Docks.

Perry’s Victory and International Peace Monument looms over the downtown. This international symbol of peace is a signature feature on South Bass Island and a stunning reminder of the War of 1812.

Downtown Bars

The bar scene on Put-in-Bay is hard to beat. With everything from fine cocktail lounges to exclusive nightclubs, weekends on the island are sure to get wild during the summer.

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill is certainly an island favorite. This friendly establishment plays live music almost every night of the summer. Their menu is full of mouthwatering entrees and filling appetizers. The Green Room sits on top of Mr. Ed’s and provides the best dancing on the island. DJ’s from all over the region spin here.

Frosty Bar is a always a hub of activity. With their signature frosty mugs full of beer, the backyard patio and Big Man’s Burrito Stand makes for an ideal hang out spot on Saturday afternoons. Live music, sports on TV, and bar games round out this friendly spot.

For something a little more intimate, try the Red Moon. Tucked away at the Park Hotel, the Red Moon mixes incredible cocktails in a speakeasy-like atmosphere. Perfect for date nights or a first stop on a Saturday night. Start your night off right at the Red Moon.


266 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA

Official Website

Write Review

Go to Top