Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Located inside the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center and right next to the Blue Marlin Tiki Bar, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is one of South Bass Island’s favorite pizza joints. This complex is located on Loraine Avenue, a short walk from the center of downtown.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Details

Dedicated to the freshest ingredients and gooiest cheese, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company delivers on flavor every time. With creative toppings and free delivery, it’s no wonder the reviews for this spot are so stellar. Open everyday from 11am – 2pm, their pizza is perfect for lunch or a quick bite before heading home after partying all night.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Menu Highlights

• Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
• Chicken Alfredo Pizza
• Hawaiian Pizza
• Fajita Chicken Grinder
• Meatball Grinder
• Fajita Chicken Grinder

Feel free to build your own pizza as well. A delicious variety of toppings and cheese are also available to make your pie just right. Green olives, green peppers, pineapple, bacon, banana peppers, and salami are just some of the mouth watering toppings offered. And extra cheese of course! They always use 100% whole milk mozzarella and fresh, flavorful sauce.

The star of the menu is the pizza, but the supporting cast is pretty excellent. With a full menu of grinders, salads, and wings, the deliciousness just keeps going. The grinders take on Italian flavors with the Stromboli Grinder, Meatball Grinder, and the Chicken Parmesan and Mexican with the popular Fajita Chicken Grinder.

The Wings and Things section of the menu include their Mac & Cheese Wedges, Mozzarella Sticks, and Ravioli Bites. The Buffalo Style Wing Dings are juicy and spiced right. Onion Rings and Fries goes with everything.

The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill

All this sounds pretty great, right? Imagine eating all this amazing food while relaxing in a luxurious pool with drink in hand. The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill also offers in-pool seating at their swim-up bar. Best of both worlds! Pizza and pools.

The Blue Marlin is situated at one of the nicest pools on the island. This beautiful pool is decked out in a tropical theme, including the thatched roof of the bar and the “palm trees” swaying in the breeze. Plenty of lounge chairs dot the deck for you to get a tan.

The centerpiece of the entire operation is definitely the hot tub. The World’s Largest Jacuzzi, this 104 degree slice of heaven also has seating for up to 40 people. Always crystal clean, the 4500 gallons water circulates and treats every 30 minutes. This ensures its cleanliness at all times.

The Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center

This large complex combines all the fun and amenities of a luxury hotel with a fully equipped meeting facility. A perfect place for both business retreats and weddings, the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center hosts hundreds of events per year. Their offerings include state-of-the-art facilities and an impressive catering menu.

The rooms and suites offered hold a variety of groups. From romantic jacuzzi suites to poolside condos, there is always something for everyone at the Resort. They also have Villas for rent. Located off-site, these impressive dwellings can house up to 12 people.

(419) 285-0504

439 Loraine Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA

Official Website

Write Review

Go to Top