Put-in-Bay Dining & Restaurant Guide

A complete Put in Bay Ohio restaurants and bars guide with contact information. Put-in-bay has no shortage of variety! From a cheeseburger in the paradise of the north to a fine dining experience, you will find what your heart desires from the list below.

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille is the central hub for food and fun on Put-in-Bay. With a mouthwatering Cameo Pizza menu, full bar, and three different entertainment venues, Mr. Ed’s serves up the best in summertime fun. Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille Details The daylight hours at Mr. Ed’s means enjoying the lake breezes on the front porch, incredible food, and plenty of HD TV’s screening your favorite teams. Mr. Ed’s is located right next to the Commodore Resort and... more information
Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Located inside the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center and right next to the Blue Marlin Tiki Bar, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is one of South Bass Island’s favorite pizza joints. This complex is located on Loraine Avenue, a short walk from the center of downtown. Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Details Dedicated to the freshest ingredients and gooiest cheese, the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company delivers on flavor every time. With creative toppings and free delivery, it’s no wonder the reviews for this spot... more information
MIST Pool Bar

MIST Pool Bar

MIST Pool Bar is the hottest pool bar on Put-in-Bay. With the all the luxuries of a resort pool and the excitement of a high-end nightclub, MIST Pool Bar is the best place to see and be seen on the island. MIST Pool Bar Details Located at the Commodore Resort, MIST is open to both guests of the Commodore and visitors and is exclusively 21+ during the summer. Local and regional DJ’s spin all weekend long to the tune of... more information
Blue Marlin

Blue Marlin

Dine poolside at the Blue Marlin Bar and Grille and enjoy the best of summertime on Put-in-Bay. Located at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center, this swim-up bar is at the center of one of the most exciting and fun locations on the island! Blue Marlin Bar & Grill Details The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill is open to both guests of the resort and the general public. Everyone can join in on the fun! The beautiful pool is decked... more information
Subway

Subway

Everyone loves Subway. Located in the lobby of the Commodore Resort and right next door to Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill, Subway on Put-in-Bay is fast, convenient, and as always, delicious. Subway Details The aroma of delicious, fresh baked bread is always the telltale sign Subway is nearby. The Commodore is located in the center of downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue and features a sign for Subway on its facade, making it easy to find. Subway is always the perfect... more information
Buckeye Tiki Bar

Buckeye Tiki Bar

The Buckeye Tiki Bar is part of the Bay Lodging Resort complex. Only a few minutes from downtown Put-in-Bay, the Buckeye is low-key spot, perfect for groups of friends looking to relax over delicious drinks and plenty of poolside fun. The Buckeye Tiki Bar Details Bay Lodging is just outside of the busy downtown on Lakeview Avenue. This gives it a chiller vibe than some of the spots right in the center of the action. It is home to the... more information
Cameo Pizza

Cameo Pizza

Cameo Pizza is a Put-in-Bay favorite. Serving up fresh, hot pizza since 1936, Cameo is a family-owned joint that puts love into everything they make. Come on down and be a part of a Put-in-Bay summer tradition with a whole pie or a slice. Big news! Cameo Pizza recently moved into Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille. Now the island’s beloved pizza joint is in everyone’s favorite bar. Pizza lovers can now sit down and enjoy a slice of this phenomenal... more information
The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s

The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s

Ready for a magical night of dancing at the hottest nightclub in Put-in-Bay? The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s makes sure every night to one to remember. With gorgeous views of Lake Erie, DeRivera Park and downtown Put-in-Bay harbor, this is the spot to be when the sun sets on the lake. The best DJ’s in the region regularly spin at The Green Room. The high energy vibe pulsates through the dance floor as everyone gets down and gets dancing.... more information
Joe’s Bar & Restaurant?
,

Joe’s Bar & Restaurant?

Welcome to “Best Dive Bar on Planet,” as Joe’s Bar & Restaurant on Put-in-Bay proclaims! With classic bar food, outdoor games, and the friendliest vibe on South Bass Island, Joe’s Bar & Restaurant is the gathering place for both island locals and summertime visitors. Joe’s Bar & Restaurant Details This gastropub is tucked away from downtown Put-in-Bay at the end of Catawba Avenue. Situated next to South Bass Island State Park, Joe’s offers up a respite from the craziness of... more information

If you are interested in reading Putinbay restaurant reviews, we recommend the Put in Bay Food Blog as a site which features a weekly column on different island eateries, bars, festivals, and anything food related that happens on our little resort island.

Many establishments serve outstanding food by day only to evolve into venues for great Putinbay entertainment by night. From one-man bands to nationally known acts, you are sure to find excitement and variety at Put-in-Bay!

More Put in Bay Bars and Restaurant Dining

Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of restaurants from a simple Subway chain restaurant to sit down fine dining venues with views that are incredible! Most of the Put-in-Bay Restaurants are located in the downtown area although there are a few in the interior of the island. One thing that you will almost always find at most Put-in-Bay Restaurants will be the highly prized delicious Lake Erie Perch. It’s served in tacos, salads, baskets, and dinners it’s that good! A close runner-up is the Walleye, another popular Lake Erie Fish.