Casual Cuisine

The most popular Put-in-Bay dining and restaurant choice is Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the low key and mellow atmosphere of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a full belly.

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille
Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille: The Heart of Put-in-Bay Fun Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille is the ultimate hub for food, drinks, and entertainment on Put-in-Bay.  Offering a delicious Cameo Pizza menu, a full bar, and three dynamic entertainment venues, this spot guarantees the best in summertime fun. Daytime Vibes During the day, Mr. Ed’s is perfect for relaxing on the front porch while soaking up the lake breezes.  With plenty of HD TVs playing your favorite sports teams, it’s also a great place to catch the big game.  Conveniently...More Information
Joe’s Bar & Restaurant
Joe’s Bar & Restaurant: A Friendly Spot on Put-in-Bay   Welcome to Joe’s Bar & Restaurant, known as the “Best Dive Bar on the Planet.” This cozy spot is a favorite for locals and visitors alike. With tasty food, outdoor games, and a relaxed vibe, it’s a great place to hang out and enjoy your time on South Bass Island.   Where to Find Joe’s Joe’s Bar is located at the quiet end of Catawba Avenue, away from the busy downtown area. It’s right next to South Bass Island State...More Information
Cameo Pizza
Cameo Pizza: A Put-in-Bay Tradition Since 1936   Put in Bay Cameo Pizza has been serving delicious, hot, fresh pizza since 1936, making it a long-standing favorite at Put-in-Bay. This family-owned pizza spot is a summer tradition for locals and visitors alike, offering everything from classic cheese to creative signature pies. Whether you’re in the mood for a whole pizza or just a slice, Cameo Pizza has you covered.   Put in Bay Cameo Pizza at Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille Cameo Pizza has moved into Mr. Ed’s Bar and...More Information
Subway
Everyone loves Subway. Located in the lobby of the Commodore Resort and right next door to Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill, Subway on Put-in-Bay is fast, convenient, and as always, delicious. Subway Details The aroma of delicious, fresh baked bread is always the telltale sign Subway is nearby. The Commodore is located in the center of downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue and features a sign for Subway on its facade, making it easy to find. Subway is always the perfect mix of sustenance and value. They make the best sandwich...More Information
Reel Bar
Reel Bar: A Favorite Hangout on Put-in-Bay   Opened in 2014 by Andy Christiansen and local musician Ray Fogg, the Reel Bar quickly became a favorite spot on Put-in-Bay. Known as “A Reel New Bar in a Reel Old Place,” this welcoming venue celebrates fishing culture with its cozy décor and lively atmosphere.   Location and Atmosphere The Reel Bar sits on the historic site of Tony’s, a beloved island hangout, and is neighbors with the Victory Station Hotel, the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society, and the Put-in-Bay Police Department....More Information
Loading...

The most popular Put-in-Bay dining and restaurant choice is Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the low key and mellow atmosphere of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a full belly.