Put-in-Bay Top Shopping

Shopping in Put-in-Bay reflects the unique charm and laid-back atmosphere that defines South Bass Island. Strolling along our quaint streets, you’ll find a wide variety of specialty shops, offering everything from resort-style clothing to unique gift items. With more than 30 retailers, the options are virtually endless. Discount stores, national and international retailers, local boutiques, furniture galleries, designer shops, specialty stores, high-end, discount – every kind of shopping in one great place – Put in Bay Ohio! Here’s our “Top Ten” recommendations for shopping on Put-in-Bay island:

LOVELLA FASHION APPAREL

258 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-5010
www.lovellafashion.com

Offering the finest apparel and accessories, Lovella has the right options for the fashion conscious. Featuring a wide selection of upscale swim suits, sunglasses and chic clothing from well known designers. Open late to better serve you. Be sure to include Lovella Fashion Apparel on your next shopping excursion to Put-in-Bay.


BAY BUCKS

Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
216-898-9951
www.putinbaybucks.com

The best value on Put-in-Bay, Bay Bucks was created with you in mind. Take advantage of the hundreds of dollars of savings by utilizing this coupon booklet. For just $6.95 you’ll find a wide range of discounts. These booklets can be purchased while vacationing on Put-in-Bay, by clicking on the link or by phone. The above cost does not include shipping costs if purchased by phone or the web. Be sure to put some money back in your pocket while on Put in Bay, and check out the savings Bay Bucks offers.


CHOCOLATE CAFE

Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2268
www.chocolateohio.com

The name alone will get your mouth watering. The Chocolate Café and Chocolate Museum at Put-in-Bay has a multitude of items relating to this favorite snack of many. The gift shop has trinkets, t-shirts and unique gifts for all of your chocolate lovers. Decadent chocolate and ice cream is also available for your delight.


CARRIAGE HOUSE

160 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2212
www.frostys.com

The premier souvenir spot at Put-in-Bay, the Carriage House’s selection is vast. There are over 600 items that bear the wonderful “Put in Bay” name. Also, there is a large collection of name personalized items, including shot glasses and stationary. Quirky hats, ping pong balls and rubber ducks are but a few of the finds at the Carriage House. Find us across from Harbor Village on Delaware Ave. in Downtown Put-in-Bay.


THE LOBSTER TRAP

Bayview Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2043
www.the-boardwalk.com

The Lobster Trap features a wide range of apparel with the Boardwalk/UPPER DECK Logo. Quirky and fun tee shirts, stylish sweatshirts and a colorful selection of children’s garments will make it hard to resist. For that special gift or unique decorative accent, The Lobster Trap is the place to shop! A nautical theme is found throughout the shop with mermaids, fish and lobsters for sale. Highlighting a sterling array of Mariposa Giftware, Barware and serving pieces, there is sure to be something that you can’t live without.


FROSTY BAR GIFTS

252 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-3278
www.frostys.com

A place synonymous with cold beer and hot pizza, Frostys has been bringing its flavor to Put-in-Bay for over 50 years. The gift shop has a variety of items bearing the recognizable logo. T-shirts, sweatshirts and glasses are but of the few choices for Frosty souvenirs. On your next visit to Put-in-Bay, take a piece of Frostys with you!


BUTTERFLY HOUSE

979 Catawaba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2446
www.perryscave.com

Inside the Perry’s Family Fun Center you’ll find the Butterfly House. Walk through this calming oasis as butterflies gently fly around you. Here you can find some great, unique gifts. Families are encouraged to shop and enjoy the free film about butterflies. Spread your wings at the Butterfly House at PIB.


PUT-IN-BAY TRADING CO.

441 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2242
NO WEBSITE

Located next to Town Hall and the PIB Police, The Put-in-Bay Trading Co. has an impressive assortment of novelty t-shirts and shorts. Most of their neat designs reflect on Put in Bay and the grandeur of the Lake Erie islands. They are a licensed Orange County Chopper merchandiser, providing gifts for all of the bikers in your family. Come to the Put-in-Bay Trading Co. and get your PIB gear.


HOME PORT & ACCESSORIES

421 Langram Rd., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-7369
https://www.facebook.com/pibshopping

Located at Compass Pointe, Home Port Gifts offers nautical inspired home decor. There’s always a sale going on and there are three other small shops in the same complex to visit, all with one stop!

Write Review

Go to Top