Chocolate Cafe and Museum

Talk about tasty! The Chocolate Cafe and Museum is perhaps the most delicious attraction on Put-in-Bay. Located a little less than a mile from downtown on Catawba Avenue, The Chocolate Cafe satisfies every visitors sweet tooth, big to small.

The Chocolate Cafe and Museum Details

One side is the cafe while the other houses the museum. The cafe allows visitors to indulge in their love of all things sweets. While they excel in the fine art of chocolates, they also serve a range of sweet and savory treats.

The Chocolate Cafe sells 32 flavors of the popular Toft’s ice cream along with decadent pastries and cakes. They also offer signature coffees that pair perfectly with their chocolates. They grind their coffee beans fresh each day. There is nothing more satisfying than a cup of piping hot coffee made fresh.

Their hot chocolate menu is also rather impressive. They make everything from spicy Mexican Hot Chocolate to their divine Dark Hot Chocolate. Make sure to add a dollop of whipped cream for the ultimate hot chocolate experience.

Starting your Put-in-Bay day at the Chocolate Cafe? Order up some of their ultra satisfying breakfast sandwiches, muffins, bagels, and more.

The Chocolate Cafe Chocolates

• Meltaways & Truffles
• Turtles & Clusters
• Chocolate Covered Favorites
• Squares & Mints
• Creams
• Solid Chocolate
• Malted Milk Balls
• Salty Chocolate Covered Pretzels
• Caramel Corn
• Gift Bags and Boxes
• Crunches
• Gift Baskets
• Fudge

Visitors grab an individual piece of Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels or a pound of Coconut Haystacks. Really there is so much to choose from White Chocolate Covered Pretzels to Milk Chocolate Rice Krispie treats you and your family will want to come time and time again. Make sure to take a box home when you leave the island.

Chocolates can be ordered online and they also offer packages for corporate events. Planning a special work event? They also create corporate branding for their chocolates. They can incorporate your logo, photo, or artwork onto bags of their delicious popcorn and boxed chocolate for something extra special.

The bakery case is full of cakes like their super rich Turtle Cheesecake, Tiramisu Sponge Cake, and Mixed Berry Cheesecake.

The Chocolate Museum

The museum features exhibition about the making of chocolate as well as displays of favorite candy colored movies like Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. One of this country’s most beloved tastes, most of us don’t know how chocolate is made. The displays include antique memorabilia from the early days of chocolate making to vintage tins and boxes.

It is said that the chocolate we enjoy today was first made in London in 1657. However, chocolate has been consumed for over 200 years when cacao was grown and produced in South and Central America.

The property includes outdoor seating as well as a Biergarten right next door. Goat Soup and Whiskey also shares this address. This spot on the island is so full of delicious food, you could spend the entire day here eating your heart out. Come for breakfast, stay for the chocolates, and finish off your day with a gourmet meal at Goat Soup and Whiskey.