Goat Soup & Whiskey

With a seasonal menu, fresh ingredients from on-site gardens, and casual fine dining, Goat Soup & Whiskey is Put-in-Bay dining at its finest. A sophisticated setting and beautiful outdoor garden greet visitors about a mile from the hustle and bustle of the downtown.

Goat Soup & Whiskey Details

Open from May 20 to September 30, service runs from 11:30 – 10pm every day. Their location on Catawba Avenue is right next to the Chocolate Cafe & Museum and up the street from Heineman Winery and Perry’s Cave and Family Fun Center.

The chefs at Goat Soup & Whiskey take pride in every dish they create. There is no better indication of this dedication than the three gardens located on the premises. The chefs use fresh herbs, fruit, and vegetables in their entrees and cocktails.

They also source a variety of berry’s from the nearby Bergman’s Orchard for both drinks and desserts. Diners are sure to taste the difference fresh ingredients make in their dish.

Their loyalty to fresh extends to their seafood. They always use freshly caught perch from Lake Erie for their prized Perch Tacos. They are even known as the “home of the perch taco.” Goat chefs delicately fry fillets of hand breaded perch and pairs them with cheese, green onion, shredded cabbage and their secret “pali wali” taco sauce in a flour tortilla.

The Perch Tacos are probably equally as well-known as their delicious homemade soups. They feature a rotating menu of soups daily, each using only the best ingredients. Your server will let you know about the soup specials as soon as you sit down.

The Goat Soup & Whiskey Menu Highlights

• Lollypop Lamp Chops
• Reuben Balls with corned beef, sauerkraut and swiss cheese, breaded and fried with a side of thousand island dressing
• Perch Sandwich
• Frieda’s Walleye a la Fran (walleye fillet crusted with parmesan breading and sautéed in garlic butter, capers and lemon)
• Seared Scallops
• Frog Legs with cajun lemon butter
• Chicken Piccata

The dinner entrees are always divinely rich. Duck breast served with ponzu sauce, seared scallops over jasmine rice, and a positively succulent blue cheese sirloin are just some of the mouth watering options. Goat Soup & Whiskey is perfect for date night or special occasions.

The wine list is quite impressive with reds and whites from every corner of the world. The beer selection will satisfy everyone’s palette with a full range of domestic and imported.

Their cocktail is mind boggling! A fun mix of fresh takes and classic favorites, feel free to get a tad adventurous. The martini menu includes everything from a Cinnamon Toast Martini to a Peaches and Cream.

Of course the fresh fruit cocktails are the perfect summer drink with the addition of locally sourced fruit. Make sure to try the Banana Bliss made with fresh bananas, Bacardi rum, fresh bananas, ice cream and creme de cacao.

Goat Soup & Whisky also features a special menu for their outdoor Biergarten. Dine al fresco in the lower front grounds and enjoy a selection of Bavarian favorites. Bratwurst, Beer Cheese Soup, and a Bavarian Pretzel all pair very well a Steigl Beer.


820 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA

Official Website

Write Review

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Go to Top