The Keys: Where Florida Meets Put-in-Bay
- Prime Location:
- The Keys welcomes visitors as they step off the Jet Express Ferry.
- A two-tiered, tropical-style building sets the perfect vacation mood.
- Signature Cocktails:
- Painkiller – A delicious blend of rum, coconut, pineapple, and orange juice.
- Rum Punch – A fruity island favorite to kickstart your getaway.
- Scenic Dining Experience:
- Enjoy breathtaking waterfront views from the outdoor decks.
- A laid-back yet luxurious atmosphere for a perfect afternoon escape.
- Island-Inspired Appetizers:
- Conch Fritters – A Bahamian classic, lightly fried and served with Key Lime Tartar Sauce.
- ½ lb Peel & Eat Shrimp – A true island-style favorite.
- Apostle Cheese Curds – Breaded Wisconsin white cheddar with Sriracha ranch.
- Must-Try Entrees:
- Perch Fillets – Lightly hand-breaded, paired with Key Lime Tartar Sauce.
- Island Tacos – A flavorful tropical twist.
- Grouper Reuben – A fresh take on a classic sandwich.
- Carnitas Rice Bowl – A hearty, savory island delight.
With incredible food, tropical drinks, and unbeatable views, The Keys is the ultimate island dining experience! 🌴🍹
The Keys Menu Highlights
- Conch Fritters – A Bahamian classic with fresh conch, onions, bell peppers, and Key Lime Tartar Sauce
- Apostle Cheese Curds – Breaded Wisconsin white cheddar cheese curds served with Sriracha ranch
- Grouper Reuben – Grilled grouper topped with coleslaw, guacamole, swiss cheese, and sweet chili tartar sauce
- Blackened Mahi Tacos – With mango slaw, avocado, fresh cilantro, and Key Lime Greek Yogurt
- Island Tacos – Choose blackened or grilled chicken, mahi mahi, or shrimp, served with fire-roasted corn and black bean rice
And let’s not forget those drinks! With the rum flowing, a perfect summer night at The Keys is on the horizon. Ask one of their expert and friendly bartenders to whip you up a Dark & Stormy made with Gosling’s Black Seal Rum and Ginger Beer.
Or go the frosty route with one of their many frozen specialty drinks like the Bermuda Triangle, a tropical twist of 151 Octane, Rum Runner and Piña Colada topped with Raspberry Peach Grand Marnier Floater.
The Keys Specialty Cocktails
- Dark & Stormy – Made with Gosling’s Black Seal Rum and Ginger Beer
- Bermuda Triangle – A frozen blend of 151 Octane, Rum Runner, Piña Colada, and Raspberry Peach Grand Marnier Floater
- Island Zombie – Rum, orange, and pineapple juice
- Cool as a Cucumber Martini – Perfectly refreshing!
And don’t forget to finish your meal with one of their mouthwatering desserts:
- Key Lime Pie – Topped with whipped cream and a lime wedge
- Pineapple Creme Brûlée – A tropical delight
- Banana Xango – Deep-fried cheesecake perfection!
Now that you’ve dined on their stellar appetizers, savored their mouthwatering entrees, and got a little wild with their cocktails, what is left but dessert!? Nothing says “The Keys” than a big slice of Key Lime pie topped with whipped cream and a lime wedge. The Pineapple Creme Brûlée and Banana Xango, a deep fried cheesecake, are pretty bananas as well!
Surprise!
Enjoy a 10% discount on your food bill when you dine at The Keys – just show your copy of the book 101 Thinks to do at Put in Bay!
Whether you’re visiting for a weekend or staying all summer, a visit to The Keys is a must! Enjoy the beautiful island scenery while savoring delicious food and drinks. Cheers to unforgettable moments at Put-in-Bay!
See You at The Bay 🙂