Yes! Reservations are available at the Goat Soup and Whiskey for groups of all sizes. The Upper Deck at the Boardwalk also accepts group reservations. All other restaurants serve on a first come first served basis. With so many Put-in-Bay restaurants available, you should be able to find seating without waiting too long.
There are many different options for Pizza on Put-in-Bay! The most popular is Cameo Pizza which can be found inside Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille. Cameo Pizza is open until 3:30 AM on weekends and offers dine in, take-out and delivery. A close second is the island's newest pizza sensation, Swipe Right Pizza, located out next to Joe's Bar and open until 2:00 AM on weekends (walking distance to the campground, Island Club, and PIB Condos).
Frosty Bar has great cheesy pizza and is open until 1:00 AM. The Put-in-Bay Brewery is another great and little known option for pizza, but with a very loyal following. Lastly, you have Put-in-Bay's most unusual pizza opportunity - the Fire Engine Pizza Company on the edge of downtown.
There are multiple places available for pizza on the Island:
- Swipe Right Pizza: (419) 742-9222
- Cameo Pizza: (419) 285-4444
- Frosty Bar: (419) 285-3278
- Put-in-Bay Brewery: (419) 285-4677
- Fire Engine Pizza Company: (419) 515-2645
Yes! If you are looking to dine on the water, you have a few options. First, you have The Keys, offering a Caribbean vibe with great tasting food and located right on the water next to the Jet Express ferry dock. The Boardwalk, on the other end of the harbor, has a lower and upper deck with multiple dining options. The Upper Deck, inside the Boardwalk, consists of fine dining and the lower deck has many a la carte options available. Located just next door, Topsy Turvey's Bar also has a sitting deck right on the water. Lastly, Dairy Isle is located next to the water if you are looking for a quick bite or some ice cream treats with a beautiful water view while you eat.
It is hard to pick just one with so many fine options. Thus, according to customer reviews, the Top 5 places for seafood in Put-in-Bay are:
- The Boardwalk
- The Keys
- The Upper Deck
- The Boathouse Bar & Grille
- Mossback's
Almost every bar and restaurant on the island has some sort of live entertainment both day and night. Some of the Best Bars for Live Entertainment on Put-in-Bay are Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille located in the Commodore Resort, the Roundhouse Bar, and the Boathouse Bar & Grille.
Here is a list of Put-in-Bay restaurants that are open late:
- Swipe Right Pizza: open until 2:00 AM
- Topsy Turvey's: open until 2:00 AM
- The Boathouse Bar & Grille: open until 2:00 AM
- Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille: open until 2:30 AM
- Subway: open until 3:00 AM
- Cameo Pizza: open until 3:30 AM
The Subway at Put-in-Bay is located inside the lobby of the Commodore Resort, next to the Mist Swim-up Bar and is carryout only. There is no dining area inside, however, there are a few chairs and tables outside the lobby where you can sit down and enjoy your meal.
According to TripAdvisor, here are the Top 10 restaurants in Put-in-Bay:
- The Forge
- Goat, Soup and Whiskey
- Pasquales Café
- Topsy Turvey's
- Hooligans
- The Keys
- ReelBar
- Upper Deck Restaurant
- Mossbacks
- The Boardwalk
Each restaurant on the island is privately owned and most open and close at the start and end of the season. However, Tippers and Topsy Turvey are usually open year-round for island residents and guests alike. On some winter weekends, Reel Bar, located across from Put-in-Bay's Grand Islander Hotel, is also open for food and entertainment.