Skip to content
Put In Bay
Put in Bay Hotel, Put in Bay Lodging, Put-in-Bay Ohio
Put In BayPut In Bay
216-898-9951
Live Chat
  • 72o
  • Blog
  • Stay
  • Put-in-Bay Island Guide
  • Put-in-Bay Gazette
  • Golf Carts
  • Free Weekend
  • FAQ’s
Top Bar Menu
Reserve Your Cart Now!
  • Lodging
    • Hotels & Resorts
    • Vacation Rentals
    • Condos
    • Houses & Cabins
    • Bed and Breakfast and Guest Houses
    • Last Minute Lodging
    • Free Weekend Contest
    • Lodging FAQ
  • Golf Cart Rentals
    • ALL Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals
    • Golf Cart Center
    • Golf Cart Depot
    • Island Club Carts
    • PIB Condos Carts
    • Golf Carts FAQ
  • Things To Do
    • ALL Put-in-Bay Attractions
    • Shopping
    • Dining
    • Family
    • Perry’s Monument
    • CampgroundsPut in Bay Ohio South Bass Island offers several camping options for your enjoyment. Put-in-Bay is an ideal setting for a family getaway at one of the Island’s peaceful and modern campgrounds.
    • Festivals & Events
    • Boating & Dockage
    • Fishing Information
    • Winter Ice Fishing
  • Put-in-Bay Events
    • ALL Upcoming Events
    • Live Entertainment
    • Island News
    • Bash on the Bay!
    • Island Club Spring Fling Party
    • Island Club Fall Ball Party
  • Restaurants
    • Featured Favorites
    • ALL Restaurants
    • Casual RestaurantsThe most popular Put-in-Bay dining and restaurant choice is Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the low key and mellow atmosphere of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a full belly.
    • Fine Dining
  • BarsThe most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife. There are also many dining and restaurant choices, such as Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the slower island vibes and life of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a smile on your face!
    • Island Hot Spots
    • ALL BarsThe most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife. There are also many dining and restaurant choices, such as Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the slower island vibes and life of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a smile on your face!
    • Live Music Bars
    • Nighttime Hotspots
    • Local/Casual Bars
    • Pool Bars
  • Webcams
  • Ferry Service
    • ALL Ferries
    • Miller Ferry Schedule
    • Jet Express Schedule
    • Miller Ferry
    • Jet Express
    • Sonny-S to Middle Bass
    • Ferry FAQ
    • Taxi Transportation
  • PIB Island Guide
    • Printable Guide
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery (soon)
    • Virtual Tours
    • Best of the Bay Awards
    • Free Weekend
    • FAQ’s
    • Helpful Area Links
    • Fly the Bay
  • PIB Info
    • Put-in-Bay Lodging
    • Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals
    • Taxi Transportation
    • Island Ferry Boats
    • Directions
    • Island News
    • Put-in-Bay Real Estate
    • General Services
    • Put-in-Bay History
    • Airport
    • FAQ’s
    • Groups & Tours
    • Put- in-Bay Weddings
    • Boating & Dockage
    • Fishing Information
    • Contact Us
    • Last Minute Lodging
    • Best of the Bay Awards
    • Middle Bass Lodging
    • Port Clinton Lodging
    • BLOG
    • Put-in-Bay Island Guide
    • Put-in-Bay Gazette
    • Free Weekend Contest
Search:
  • Lodging
    • Hotels & Resorts
    • Vacation Rentals
    • Condos
    • Houses & Cabins
    • Bed and Breakfast and Guest Houses
    • Last Minute Lodging
    • Free Weekend Contest
    • Lodging FAQ
  • Golf Cart Rentals
    • ALL Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals
    • Golf Cart Center
    • Golf Cart Depot
    • Island Club Carts
    • PIB Condos Carts
    • Golf Carts FAQ
  • Things To Do
    • ALL Put-in-Bay Attractions
    • Shopping
    • Dining
    • Family
    • Perry’s Monument
    • CampgroundsPut in Bay Ohio South Bass Island offers several camping options for your enjoyment. Put-in-Bay is an ideal setting for a family getaway at one of the Island’s peaceful and modern campgrounds.
    • Festivals & Events
    • Boating & Dockage
    • Fishing Information
    • Winter Ice Fishing
  • Put-in-Bay Events
    • ALL Upcoming Events
    • Live Entertainment
    • Island News
    • Bash on the Bay!
    • Island Club Spring Fling Party
    • Island Club Fall Ball Party
  • Restaurants
    • Featured Favorites
    • ALL Restaurants
    • Casual RestaurantsThe most popular Put-in-Bay dining and restaurant choice is Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the low key and mellow atmosphere of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a full belly.
    • Fine Dining
  • BarsThe most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife. There are also many dining and restaurant choices, such as Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the slower island vibes and life of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a smile on your face!
    • Island Hot Spots
    • ALL BarsThe most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife. There are also many dining and restaurant choices, such as Casual Dining. Island visitors enjoy the slower island vibes and life of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a smile on your face!
    • Live Music Bars
    • Nighttime Hotspots
    • Local/Casual Bars
    • Pool Bars
  • Webcams
  • Ferry Service
    • ALL Ferries
    • Miller Ferry Schedule
    • Jet Express Schedule
    • Miller Ferry
    • Jet Express
    • Sonny-S to Middle Bass
    • Ferry FAQ
    • Taxi Transportation
  • PIB Island Guide
    • Printable Guide
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery (soon)
    • Virtual Tours
    • Best of the Bay Awards
    • Free Weekend
    • FAQ’s
    • Helpful Area Links
    • Fly the Bay
  • PIB Info
    • Put-in-Bay Lodging
    • Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals
    • Taxi Transportation
    • Island Ferry Boats
    • Directions
    • Island News
    • Put-in-Bay Real Estate
    • General Services
    • Put-in-Bay History
    • Airport
    • FAQ’s
    • Groups & Tours
    • Put- in-Bay Weddings
    • Boating & Dockage
    • Fishing Information
    • Contact Us
    • Last Minute Lodging
    • Best of the Bay Awards
    • Middle Bass Lodging
    • Port Clinton Lodging
    • BLOG
    • Put-in-Bay Island Guide
    • Put-in-Bay Gazette
    • Free Weekend Contest

Top 10 Restaurant Questions

Can you make reservations for Put-in-Bay Restaurants?

Yes! Reservations are available at the Goat Soup and Whiskey for groups of all sizes. The Upper Deck at the Boardwalk also accepts group reservations. All other restaurants serve on a first come first served basis. With so many Put-in-Bay restaurants available, you should be able to find seating without waiting too long.

What are the options for Pizza on Put-in-Bay?

There are many different options for Pizza on Put-in-Bay! The most popular is Cameo Pizza which can be found inside Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille. Cameo Pizza is open until 3:30 AM on weekends and offers dine in, take-out and delivery. A close second is the island's newest pizza sensation, Swipe Right Pizza, located out next to Joe's Bar and open until 2:00 AM on weekends (walking distance to the campground, Island Club, and PIB Condos).

Frosty Bar has great cheesy pizza and is open until 1:00 AM. The Put-in-Bay Brewery is another great and little known option for pizza, but with a very loyal following. Lastly, you have Put-in-Bay's most unusual pizza opportunity - the Fire Engine Pizza Company on the edge of downtown.

What is the number for Pizza on Put-in-Bay?

There are multiple places available for pizza on the Island:

  • Swipe Right Pizza: (419) 742-9222
  • Cameo Pizza: (419) 285-4444
  • Frosty Bar: (419) 285-3278
  • Put-in-Bay Brewery: (419) 285-4677
  • Fire Engine Pizza Company: (419) 515-2645
Are there any Put-in-Bay restaurants on the water?

Yes! If you are looking to dine on the water, you have a few options. First, you have The Keys, offering a Caribbean vibe with great tasting food and located right on the water next to the Jet Express ferry dock. The Boardwalk, on the other end of the harbor, has a lower and upper deck with multiple dining options. The Upper Deck, inside the Boardwalk, consists of fine dining and the lower deck has many a la carte options available. Located just next door, Topsy Turvey's Bar also has a sitting deck right on the water. Lastly, Dairy Isle is located next to the water if you are looking for a quick bite or some ice cream treats with a beautiful water view while you eat.

What is the best place for seafood on Put-in-Bay?

It is hard to pick just one with so many fine options. Thus, according to customer reviews, the Top 5 places for seafood in Put-in-Bay are:

  1. The Boardwalk
  2. The Keys
  3. The Upper Deck
  4. The Boathouse Bar & Grille
  5. Mossback's
What is the best restaurant/bar for live entertainment?

Almost every bar and restaurant on the island has some sort of live entertainment both day and night. Some of the Best Bars for Live Entertainment on Put-in-Bay are Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille located in the Commodore Resort, the Roundhouse Bar, and the Boathouse Bar & Grille.

What restaurants are open late on Put-in-Bay?

Here is a list of Put-in-Bay restaurants that are open late:

  • Swipe Right Pizza: open until 2:00 AM
  • Topsy Turvey's: open until 2:00 AM
  • The Boathouse Bar & Grille: open until 2:00 AM
  • Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille: open until 2:30 AM
  • Subway: open until 3:00 AM
  • Cameo Pizza: open until 3:30 AM
Where is the Subway restaurant?

The Subway at Put-in-Bay is located inside the lobby of the Commodore Resort, next to the Mist Swim-up Bar and is carryout only. There is no dining area inside, however, there are a few chairs and tables outside the lobby where you can sit down and enjoy your meal.

What Put-in-Bay Restaurants have the best reviews on TripAdvisor?

According to TripAdvisor, here are the Top 10 restaurants in Put-in-Bay:

  1. The Forge
  2. Goat, Soup and Whiskey
  3. Pasquales Café
  4. Topsy Turvey's
  5. Hooligans
  6. The Keys
  7. ReelBar
  8. Upper Deck Restaurant
  9. Mossbacks
  10. The Boardwalk
What Put-in-Bay restaurants are open year round?

Each restaurant on the island is privately owned and most open and close at the start and end of the season. However, Tippers and Topsy Turvey are usually open year-round for island residents and guests alike. On some winter weekends, Reel Bar, located across from Put-in-Bay's Grand Islander Hotel, is also open for food and entertainment.

Put-in-Bay, Put In Bay Island Hotel Resort Conference Center

Put-in-Bay Ohio

Email: seo@putinbay.com


Facebook page opens in new window
X page opens in new window
Pinterest page opens in new window
YouTube page opens in new window

Put-in-Bay, OH
63°
Fog
6 am7 am8 am9 am10 am
61°F
61°F
63°F
63°F
63°F
Put-in-Bay, OH weather forecast ▸

“There are several tales to the creative name Put-in-Bay still holds to this day, the most common theory, is that of the sailors. The theory conveys that the unique name most likely originated from the sailors who would seek refuge on the bay, as it provides safe dockage. It is said when it was too rough to sail-they would “put in the bay”.

Quick Menu
  • BayTalk
  • Area Links
  • Advertising
  • Link To Us
  • Sitemap
  • Summer Internship
  • Bay Bucks
  • RSS Feed
  • Contact Us
  • Mission Statement
  • Put-in-Bay Coronavirus Response
  • Put in Bay Wiki
  • Put in Bay Reservations
  • Put-in-Bay Ohio
  • Put in Bay Lodging
  • Island Club – Put in Bay Home Rentals
  • Put-in-Bay’s Commodore Resort
  • Brand New Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos
  • Victory Station Hotel – Put-in-Bay’s Newest Downtown Lodging
© 2025 Put In Bay | All rights reserved

Cleveland Web Design | Ohio Web Technologies

Go to Top